What Is the Concept of 'Pound-Years'?

Overweight and obesity in children have become significant problems and are not to be ignored. English School, 20th century. Private Collection.

Source: Copyright Look and Learn/Bridgeman Images. Used with permission.

We first meet J. K. Rowlings' nasty Dudley Dursley as he throws his cereal at the wall. Dudley, who hates exercise and is prone to temper tantrums, is “very fat” and, in fact, "four times the size of his cousin” Harry Potter, whom he persistently torments when Harry comes to live with his muggle relatives (1980).

And poor bespectacled Piggy, the most intelligent of the shipwrecked boys, is teased and ultimately savagely killed in William Golding’s classic fable Lord of the Flies (1954).

Describing them as bullies or bullied, literature has not been kind to fat children.

"A nice new picture book--as a sequel to the famous children's work 'Der Struwwelpeter'" by W.P. Razoux/Heinrich Hoffmann. HM Roelants, Publisher. Dutch, 1849.

Source: Wikimedia Commons/Public Domain.

Fat children do not fare that well in reality either. The emotional social stigma involved in being fat is so pervasive that some in the "body activism" movement recommend not using the word obesity and not "medicalizing" obesity by referring to it as a disease (Marcus et al, 2022).

But the more we learn of the significant physical morbidities, such as hypertension, type 2 diabetes, and other metabolic abnormalities associated with chronic overweight and obesity, the more we should be concerned and not ignore when children develop excess fat during childhood and maintain the fat into adulthood.

The fat boy Joe, who consumed great quantities of food and constantly fell asleep in any situation, from Dickens' "Pickwick Papers," after which the "Pickwickian Syndrome" was named. Artist: Joseph Clayton (Kyd) Clarke, 1923. Private collection.

Source: Bridgeman Images. Used with permission

By statistics from the 2017-2018 National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES), for those aged 2 to 19, the prevalence of obesity, defined as at or above the 95th percentile on sex-specific growth charts, is 19.3%, including 6.1% with severe obesity. An additional 16% are overweight (85th to 95th percentile.) Certain populations have even high rates (Fryar et al, 2020; National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases).

Statistics from 2017-2020 (CDC) indicate even greater percentages—19.7% of those 2 to 19-year-olds are obese—14.7 million children and adolescents. These percentages have all increased exponentially since the early 1960s.

Severe obesity, defined by CDC growth charts as 120% of the 95th percentile, is an "escalating problem" that has "increased two-fold" in the last 20 years. It carries a considerable "disease burden" and is the "most prominent clinical risk factor" for type 2 diabetes, including in children as young as 3.5 years (Bendor et al, 2020.) But the effects are not just immediate.

Importantly, in long-term studies, severe obesity in adolescence is associated with adult heart failure (Sweden) and even an increased risk of cancer in adulthood (Israel) (Bendor et al).

It is not just those children and adolescents with severe obesity that warrant concern. In general, exposure to excess fat, in a dose-response relationship (i.e., the greater the excess fat, the worse the consequences) over time, may lead to an increased disease burden.

"White Lucky Strike Cigarette packs" (acrylic) by Canadian artist Jennifer Abbott. The concept of "pound-years" by Joshi and Hill is analogous to "pack-years" of smokers--intensity and duration of exposure.

Source: Copyright Jennifer Abbott. All Rights Reserved 2023/Bridgeman Images. Used with permission.

Typically, obese children will remain obese into adulthood (Skelton and Klish, 2023.) Many factors contribute, including the age of onset of obesity, its severity, and obesity in one or both parents. For example, of obese six-year-olds with an obese parent, 50% will remain obese as adults, and among obese adolescents (10-to-14-year-olds), 80% will remain so. Children with severe obesity at age five have a 90% chance of remaining obese into mid-adulthood (Skelton and Klish).

The fascinating concept of pound-years was first delineated in an editorial by Texas researchers Joshi and Hill (2017.) It is analogous to pack-years of smokers, i.e., the number of packs smoked per day (intensity) multiplied by the cumulative number of years of exposure to tobacco (duration) (Lowell et al, 1956; Hummel, 1964; Pleasants et al, 2020; National Cancer Institute, 2023).

English artist Elizabeth Nourse, "Woman with Cigarette." Circa 1895. Photographer: Americangallery.wordpress.com. Long-term exposure to obesity may be as detrimental to health as long-term tobacco exposure.

Source: Wikimedia Commons/Public Domain.

Pound-years, then, refers to the amount or "dose," as it were, of obesity multiplied by years of exposure to the excess fat state. Joshi and Hill were responding to results from the long-term Bogalusa Study, with a mean follow-up of 28 years of over 700 adults (Zhang et al, 2017.) This study, which included multiple measurements during childhood and adulthood, concluded "increased childhood BMI has a long-term adverse impact" on the heart (Zhang et al).

Joshi and Hill explain, "With increasing pound-years of exposure, there are important myocardial structural changes" including increased left ventricular mass and hypertrophy that may be associated with ultimate heart failure. In other words, longer exposure to obesity "is an important risk factor for structural mediators of clinical disease" (2017).

Diet Essential Reads

Are These Plant Molecules the Secret to Brain Health?

Is Bariatric Surgery Right for You?

Joshi and Hill emphasize they cannot provide direct evidence of underlying mechanisms, and many factors may contribute, but "nevertheless, accumulating data suggest a strong link between obesity and structural changes of the heart," and the longer the exposure, possibly the more detrimental (2017).

Other researchers (Reilly and Kelly, 2011; Twig et al, 2016; Robertson et al, 2019; and Suri et al, 2021) have all noted the long-term consequences of excess weight that develops in children and/or adolescents.

Atmore's Mince Meat and Genuine English Plum Pudding. Illustration for trade card, late 19th or early 20th century. Excessive intake of insulin-stimulating carbohydrates can lead to obesity.

Source: Look and Learn/Barbara Loe Collection/Bridgeman Images. Used with permission.

More recently, childhood obesity, in a systematic review of eight prospective cohort studies, has been associated with kidney disorders in adulthood (Pourghazi et al, 2023.) It is likely that the more we study chronic exposure to excess weight over time, the more likely we will find associations with other pathology in a dose-response relationship.

Further, the concept of pound-years, i.e., intensity and duration of exposure—was delineated in the context of child and adolescent obesity. The concept is so important that it is worth applying to those who gain excess weight as adults and maintain that excess weight over the years.

For a more thorough discussion of inferring causation in epidemiological studies, see Rothman (1976) and Rothman and Greenland (2005.) For a heartfelt- memoir of childhood obesity, see Frank Bruni's Born Round: A Story of Family, Food, and a Ferocious Appetite (2010).